Trope Tuesday

Trope Tuesday | Biphobic Tropes That Need To Die

TropeTuesday (1)Welcome back to another Trope Tuesday! This is a weekly meme hosted by A.J. @ Lacy Literacy where we discuss a specific trope and decide: yes, indifferent, or throw it off a cliff?

Today I’m going to be talking about something near and dear to my heart: biphobia in YA.

(TW: biphobia, slut-shaming, brief discussion of ableist language.)

a brief note on terminology

Biphobia, simply put, is “fear or hatred of bisexuals, pansexuals, omnisexuals, and anyone who doesn’t otherwise fall within the binary gay or straight” (according to STFU Biphobia). Biphobia often manifests itself as stereotypical misunderstandings of bisexuals, but it goes far beyond the stereotypes and into the structure of our society. (For more on that, I’m going to refer you to Shiri Eisner’s blog, as well as her amazing book, Bi: Notes for a Bisexual Revolution.)

It should be stated that each of these harmful stereotypes has appeared in my life on the (RARE) occasions when I talk to people about being bi—whether they’re said outright or implied. Biphobia hurts—and sometimes it kills.

For the sake of time, I’m not going to argue why biphobic stereotypes are harmful, but rather how I see them reflected again and again, often in books targeted to queer and questioning teens.

fullsizeoutput_277b

biphobic tropes

#1: Bisexuals are “confused” and/or on their way to coming out as gay.

Somehow, despite the fact that most teenagers are arguably confused about a lot of things in life, the bisexual character’s confusion is seen as some sort of character flaw.

Take Avery, in Maureen Johnson’s The Bermudez Triangle: time and again, Avery comes across as confused about her sexuality, because while she’s in love with a girl, she knows she isn’t gay. Instead of using this as an opportunity to talk about sexual fluidity and how it’s okay to be confused when you’re young, Avery’s inability to embrace lesbianism is treated as a character flaw. Instead of acknowledging that—SHOCKER—it’s okay to not label your sexuality, this is treated as her being too chicken to come out as gay.

Additionally, it implies that it’s “easier” to come out as bi than to come out as gay—which is not only untrue, but drives a bigger wedge between the different parts of the queer community. Coming out is a personal decision. For some people, it’s not safe to come out—whatever their letter is in the LGBTQIA+ acronym. I wish we would stop telling other people how they need to come out a certain way.

#2: Bisexuals are natural cheaters.

Folks seem to really struggle with the fact that someone can be attracted to multiple genders and still be in a committed relationship. There’s this idea that the more people you’re potentially attracted to, the more likely you are to run off with someone of another gender, regardless of your commitments. There’s an implication that bisexuals “can’t help it” which leads people to blame a person’s sexuality for a decision they’ve made.

This trope has gotten super sneaky too. Now, coded bisexual characters don’t even have to claim the label to get branded the non-monosexual cheater: this happens with multiple characters in Sara Farizan’s Tell Me Again How a Crush Should Feel (for more on that, check out my review).

This is what I don’t get: why is being unfaithful to a partner considered worse when a bi person cheats with a different gender from their current partner? In other words, why is flipping between genders considered worse than same-gender cheating or heterosexual cheating? Oh right! Because the existence of bisexuality is super threatening to the gender binary.

#3: Bisexuals are sluts.

Bisexual characters—particularly female-bodied bisexuals—are often hypersexualized, often to the extent of becoming the Predatory Queer stereotype.

This stereotype often shows itself from the perspective of straight characters, who assume that being attracted to more than one gender means you’ll sleep with anyone. In Nora Olsen’s Frenemy of the People, Clarissa tells her friends that she’s bi, and one of them “jokes” that she doesn’t want to go bra shopping with her anymore and refers to Clarissa as “perv girl.”

The hypersexualized and slut-shamed bisexual character often appears in gay/lesbian stories as well. In Tell Me Again How a Crush Should Feel, the coded bisexual antagonist treats her multiple sexual partners like objects and uses sleeping with guys to manipulate the lesbian main character. This character is treated as “crazy” and “psycho”—because of her manipulative behavior, in part, but also because she’s going around having lots of emotionless sex.

Nobody’s sexuality should be policed by anyone else. Sex should always be between consenting individuals, and it shouldn’t be weaponized or used to hurt people. But for some reason, it’s always the coded bisexual characters who get called sluts and “psychos”—and it’s not okay.

#4: bisexuals have to “prove” their sexuality by dating the genders they’re attracted to.

This is actually the #1 reason I don’t talk to people about being bi: because their immediate response is “but I’ve never seen you dating a girl!” For some reason, when I character comes out as bisexual, it’s implied—or even stated, that they need to somehow “prove” their identity, usually by revealing their dating or sexual history. If said character hasn’t been with one or more genders they’re attracted to, then it’s seen as proof that they’re just confused.

This happens in Frenemy of the People. When Clarissa tells Lexie (an out lesbian) that she identifies as bisexual, Lexie scoffs and proceeds to ask her “how do you really know? Have you ever even kissed a girl?”

Which is funny, because I’ve heard plenty of gay folks talk about how they knew they were gay when they were four, before they had the word for it, before they’d ever kissed anyone of any gender. Yet for some reason, gay and straight people aren’t questioned when they declare their sexuality—only bisexuals have the burden of proof.

fullsizeoutput_277b

This is just the tip of the iceberg that is biphobia—and it’s going to sink our beautiful queer ship if we don’t address it. I could keep going on for another 1,000 words, but instead I’m going to leave you with a couple recommendations for some awesome, bi-affirming books I’ve read recently and bi books that are on my TBR. You can also check out my bi shelf on Goodreads.

bi books I’ve read

 

Far From You by Tess Sharpe | Noteworthy by Riley Redgate | How to Make a Wish by Ashley Herring Blake | Empress of the World by Sara Ryan

my bi TBR

 

Ramona Blue by Julie Murphey | The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue by Mackeni Lee | A Map of Home by Randa Jarrar | Teenage Rewrite by Brandon Williams

fullsizeoutput_277b

If you are bisexual, pansexual, or even if you don’t label your sexuality: please know that you can always vent to me. You are 100% beautiful and valid exactly as you are, and no one can take your identity from you. I love you.

Have you encountered any of these biphobic stereotypes in queer YA lately? Know of any great bi rep that’s not on my list (especially bi men!!)? Let’s talk in the comments!

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “Trope Tuesday | Biphobic Tropes That Need To Die”

  1. Thank you so much for this post, Christine! I hate seeing biphobia in real life and in the media and can’t seem to escape it anywhere. A lot of people don’t even realize it’s happening, so it’s really important to raise awareness!

    1. Aww, I’m really glad you liked it! It’s something that tends to hide beneath the surface of a lot of conversations, and it’s hard to catch. I see it a lot and half the time I don’t say anything because I STILL feel like I’m making it up, or overreacting. It’s nice to know that I’m not the only one who cares about these things. ❤

  2. I’m visiting your blog from Marie’s SFATW blog-hopping post and I just wanted to say that this post is freaking AWESOME. Thanks for sharing it. I’ve added a few of the books you recommended to my “To Read” list. 🙂 Thanks for bringing up an important topic!

  3. Oh my god, biphobia literally is going to be my cause of death someday. It’s just so gross and just why??? There’s no need to be gross and biphobic??? Nobody wants or needs you to be biphobic??? And then most of the time even if there isn’t blatant biphobia there’s bi-erasure. As a bi person it’s so annoying to see these tropes in media and I just. (Also a note, one of the grossest biphobic books I’ve ever had the displeasure of reading is Look Both Ways.)

    Also your blog is so nice and you have such nice posts !! ❤ ❤

    1. UGH I’m so glad to know that I’m not the only one who notices these things! It sucks that as bi people we have to fight for our very existence in the world, but it is so unbelievably nice to read comments like this one that remind me that I’m not alone.

      I’ve heard of Look Both Ways, I think. It was on my TBR at one point and then I heard about the biphobia and I was just so disappointed. Also, didn’t it get nominated for the YA Bisexual Book award this year? WTF!!!

      1. Yeah, I’ve met so many people who will be accepting of some sexual and gender identities but not all and it makes me so sad 😦

        I started look both ways but I wasn’t super into it and then I spoiled it for myself and I’m so glad I didn’t finish it. That fact that it got nominated also makes me super sad 😦

        1. RIGHT?! I’M ENRAGED. I’m all for books that explore sexuality outside of specific identities, but the fact is that there’s so little bi rep, and so little GOOD bi rep, that we don’t have time for people who are screwing it up.

          If you’re interested in other folks ranting about awful bi rep, Ann Elise has an amazing series on how authors can do better that is SO VALIDATING: https://annelisemontewriter.wordpress.com/2017/06/28/for-authors-how-not-to-be-a-dick-to-bisexuals-part-3/

  4. This is a really great post. I wrote about the same for Bi Visibility 2015, largely because I was sick of seeing so many stereotypes popping up and being taken as representative of the whole. Great job here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s